There are failing point to all bumpers the key thing to look for is the mounting points not being in single shear. I ripped my Shockworks gen one bumper off at Pismo. Granted that was after 3hrs of recover and we all just got tired so instead of using a strap I kept my winch line out so my friend can give me a tug with me still hooked up to the vehicle being recovered.
After getting a tube bumper build I am all for welding bumpers on the frame.
I also caution any shop that say they will do mass production for you. Ask the right questions, will there be a Jig to ensure correct fit and quality.
